Mark R Barton ("MRB") implements great envelopes (such as the VM 2500 ones you mentioned). My go-to 'analogue-style' envelope is the MRB Velocity Envelope. It behaves exactly like a genuine hardware circuit ADSR / AD / AR. It will react to changing Sustain levels in real-time, even whilst holding a note.Jean d'Oran wrote: ↑Fri Dec 15, 2023 9:37 pm I noticed that for all the ADSR modules that I tried, with a long decay and a sustain set very low, 0 to 50% for example, only the VM 2500 envelope generators and the Slap hitting envelope from Vult effectively raise the envelope voltage to 5 Volts if I raise the Sustain value during the game. For all the others, the voltage remains where it was from its decrease when I modify the value of the Sustain. Is this a correctable problem ?
I think it's a very bad idea to permanently modify the behaviour of existing modules, as that could modify the sound / response of existing patches / presets. The correct way to do this (in my opinion) is if you implement a new optional / switchable behaviour. In addition, this setting must always default to the existing behaviour so that it doesn't interfere with previously created patches.Is this a correctable problem ?
I asked Andrew Macaulay if he would modify the behaviour of two of his envelope generators. His solution was fantastic, exceeding my request in a very creative way. The important thing was that if these modules had been used in patches with the earlier version, then the patches would sound exactly the same when they were recalled with the updated module version.
